To some, he is the Catholic Church's
intellectual salvation during a time of confusion and compromise. To
others, he is an intimidating "Enforcer", punishing liberal thinkers,
and keeping the Church in the Middle Ages. Certainly, in the world's
largest Christian community the Pope's prefect of doctrine, Cardinal
Joseph Ratzinger, cannot be overlooked.
Against dissent
While many theologians strive for
a Catholic Church that is more open and in touch with the world around
it, Ratzinger's mission is to stamp out dissent, and curb the "wild
excesses" of this more tolerant era.
He wields the tools of his office
with steely efficiency. By influencing diocese budgets, bishops'
transfers and even excommunications, what an opponent calls "symbolic
violence", Ratzinger has clamped down on the more radical contingent of
the Church.
He has even claimed the prime
position of the Church of Rome over other Christian Churches. Although
he has apologised for this, he has never been so contrite about
excluding liberation theologians, more progressive priests or those in
favour of the ordination of women.
Charming
Personally charming, quick-witted
and fluent in four languages, the Cardinal is a convincing orator.
Jesuit Father Thomas Reese calls him "a delightful dialogue partner",
but adds that most of the Cardinal's fellow clergy would be too worried
about the prospect of excommunication to enjoy talking to him.
When Ratzinger served the Second
Vatican Council for three years from 1962, he supported reform. His own
background, however, perhaps sheds light on his need for a Church that
stands firm against the currents of change and political shifts.
Schooled in the Nazis' power of
rhetoric during his childhood in Bavaria, Ratzinger later deserted the
German Army during World War II, only to be sent to a POW camp when the
Allies reached his hometown.
Later, as an eminent theologian
lecturing at Germany's premier faculties, he was horrified by the
Marxist ideologies that punctuated campus small talk in the late 1960s.
"Papal fundamentalism"
Since then, Ratzinger has pursued
doctrine that can endure, independent of cultural or social trends. He
argues that only with a completely separate values system can the Church
offer individual freedom. His critics call this "papal fundamentalism",
but Ratzinger is unflappable in his personal theology.
The Cardinal claims that "everything
falls apart without truth". Whether his noble aims justify his tactics
is just one of the issues challenging the Catholic Church today.